Comments on: Rotation spot’s tighten; Rotation’s anyone’s guess

By: winchester

winchester — Sun, 29 Mar 2009 02:23:42 +0000

No way North Bay…Cahill doesn’t have a shot in hell to break camp with the team. He needs time in AAA. Anderson maybe, but Cahill is a no go. I agree with Ken Rosenthal, who said the A’s should go after guys like Jeff Niemann or Jason Hammel, who ever loses the 5th starter job in Tb, because they don’t have options left. They wouldn’t command much in a trade, and could fill in a gap until Gio and Duke get back.
Braden
Gallagher
Eveland
Niemann/Hammel
Outman

Thats what I want to see. I think Anderson could use some work in AAA, plus we get that crucial extra year of control

By: KFinkas

KFinkas — Fri, 27 Mar 2009 16:00:06 +0000

Cahill I’m not so sure of. His last couple outings have’nt gone well so we’ll see. I’m in Arizona now and will be relaying anything insightful to you guys. Anderson vs. Peavy today! See if he can keep the momentum.

By: NorthBayFan

NorthBayFan — Fri, 27 Mar 2009 06:15:25 +0000

I think it is pretty well set now, 1.Braden 2.Gallagher 3. Eveland 4. Anderson 5. Cahill
That is the way I predict it. Andrew Bailey will get the nod for relief duty too.

By: winchester

winchester — Wed, 25 Mar 2009 14:57:16 +0000

It doesn’t matter when they spend their time in the Minors, they just have to spend time there…but you CAN NOT start the guy in the rotation, have him dominate, then send him back down when Duke and Gio are healthy just to gain an extra year of controll on him…If he is pitching well then he is going to be PISSED that your sending him down just to get him an extra year. Doing that would burn all bridges between the team and player, and probably would effect a lot of the prospects we have coming up, seeing how we treated that one…….

By: NorthBayFan

NorthBayFan — Wed, 25 Mar 2009 06:13:44 +0000

Is the free agebt rule, that the player STARTS the season on the roster or that they spend anytime over the season on the roster. I think they should give the ball to Anderson or Cahill who ever earns it between now and then.

By: winchester

winchester — Wed, 25 Mar 2009 02:06:37 +0000

I love our prospects as much as the next A’s fan, but I’m really in the boat that they are not ready. Clearly Vin Mazzaro wasn’t but Anderson and Cahill have both struggled at times, and I would hate to sacrifice a little of the future for 2009, when we have so many q’s. Plus, with them in the rotation, that means they become free agents in 2014, as opposed to if they start in the minors, 2015. I would love one more year of control of them in the PRIME as opposed to a year when you have no clue what your going to get.
I believe the rotation should look like this:
Braden
Gallagher
Eveland
Duke (i read he will be ready for the 4 spot)
Gio (needs to get healthy fast…)
if Gio absolutly cannot Edgar Gonzalez.. EW
I think we should get Shane Komine back for a couple weeks until gio is healthy…LOL
WIth the way Outman is pitching against the Royals right now, He doesn’t deserve it yet. Maybe if he gives quality innings the rest of ST it can be him, but it would be hard to stick him in the rotation looking like the way he is now.